Personal Productivity
Why You Can No Longer Trust Your Memory (And It’s Not Your Fault)
AUTHOR: María Sáez
It’s 11 p.m., you’re about to fall asleep, and suddenly it hits you: you promised a client you’d send them the quote today. Or maybe you don’t even remember, and you find out the next morning from a somewhat sharp email. Almost all of us have experienced some version of this scenario, and we tend to respond in the same way: “I need to be more disciplined,” “I need to pay closer attention.” But the problem rarely lies in our attitude. We’re asking our memory to do a job it isn’t designed for, and the conditions we live in make it even more difficult.
Remembering the future
Psychologists distinguish between retrospective memory—which allows us to recall what has already happened—and prospective memory—which allows us to remember to do something at the right time. It’s the latter that comes into play when we need to call the doctor, review a contract, or buy bread on our way home. The work of Gilles Einstein and Mark McDaniel 1, pioneers in this field, showed that prospective memory depends largely on cues from the environment: we remember to buy bread because we walk past the bakery, not because our mind has been repeating it all day long.
When that cue doesn’t appear—or appears at the wrong time—the intention is lost. And it’s not because you’re absent-minded (though that doesn’t mean you aren’t, either). Key Dismukes, a researcher at NASA 2, spent years studying prospective memory failures in professional pilots, who follow very rigorous procedures, and found that even they forget critical steps when an interruption disrupts the usual sequence of what they’re doing. If this happens to a pilot with thousands of flight hours, we should stop interpreting our own lapses as an attitude problem.
Why it’s harder today than ever before
Added to this natural fragility are three circumstances specific to our times. The first is volume. Commitments no longer come only in meetings or in writing: they come via email, chat, instant messaging, a casual remark in the hallway, or a video call. Each channel generates small promises (“I’ll look into it,” “We’ll talk about it next week”) that are rarely recorded anywhere.
The second is the disappearance of cues. Before, each context had its own physical location: the office, home, the bank. Today, almost everything takes place in front of the same screen, and the screen itself doesn’t remind us of anything. Without distinct cues for each context, prospective memory is left without its main points of reference.
The third factor is capacity. Working memory—the mental space where we process information in real time—is surprisingly small. In 2001, Nelson Cowan 3 proposed that we can only keep about four items active at a time. To expect that space to accommodate the dozens of open commitments that any professional accumulates is, quite simply, ridiculous.
The price of trying
However, the worst part isn’t forgetting things, but rather the cost of trying not to. Unfinished tasks tend to demand our attention. This is the idea that Bluma Zeigarnik popularized in the 1920s, although subsequent replications of her original experiment have yielded mixed results. Work by E. J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister (2011) 4 was more solid: participants with pending goals experienced more intrusive thoughts and performed worse on unrelated tasks. Their most interesting finding came later: simply formulating a specific plan for that goal, without needing to complete it, was enough to make the interfering thoughts disappear.
That background noise is what many people describe as a vague sense of anxiety, the constant feeling that something is slipping away from us. We don’t know what it is, but we can feel it.
Getting commitments out of your head
The solution isn’t to train your memory, but to stop using it for things it isn’t suited for. Psychologists Evan Risko and Sam Gilbert call this cognitive offloading 5: using your environment (a note, a reminder, a list) to reduce the burden on your mind. And cognitive offloading does more than just prevent forgetfulness. In 2015, Benjamin Storm and Sean Stone 6 observed that when people knew information was stored in a safe place, they were more likely to remember new information that came afterward. Freeing up mental space allows you to use it for something else.
However, simply writing things down isn’t enough. A list that isn’t consulted, or that only includes half of your commitments, doesn’t put anyone’s mind at ease. The mind remains on guard because it doesn’t trust it. For your memory to truly let go of the burden, an external system must bring everything together in a place you trust and turn each commitment into a specific next step. Furthermore, it must be reviewed often enough so that no promise is quietly forgotten.
A mind for thinking
These three conditions are nothing new. They are, in fact, the starting point for personal organization methodologies such as GTD, which David Allen summarized in an idea that today sounds almost like a diagnosis: the mind is for having ideas, not for storing them. Perhaps the first step isn’t to remember better, but to stop needing to.
Reference material
1 Einstein & McDaniel (1990), Normal Aging and Prospective Memory, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition.
2 Dismukes (2012), Prospective Memory in Workplace and Everyday Situations, Current Directions in Psychological Science.
3 Cowan (2001), The magical number 4 in short-term memory, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.
4 Masicampo & Baumeister (2011), Consider it done!, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
5 Risko & Gilbert (2016), Cognitive Offloading, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.
6 Storm & Stone (2015), Saving-Enhanced Memory, Psychological Science.


No comments